Home and Auto Insurance Carrier Phone Numbers

Quick access to answers.

Below are a list of our home and auto insurance carrier general and claims phone numbers. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact a PSA representative at 800.677.7887.

Insurance Carrier General Claims
Ace Insurance 800.444.6161 800.945.7461, press 1
AIC 800.492.5629 800.492.5629
AIG Private Client 866.856.6858 888.760.9195
Brethren Mutual 800.621.4264 800.621.4262, press 3
Chubb Insurance 800.248.2275 800.252.4670, press 1
Cincinnati Insurance 513.870.2882 877.242.2544
Encompass Insurance 877.870.3277 800.588.7400, press 2
Farmers Insurance 800.597.2548 800.355.6458
Fireman’s Fund Insurance 866.386.3932 800.347.3428, press 1
Foremost Auto 800.274.7865 800.274.7865
Harleysville Insurance 800.338.8301 800.892.8877
Hartford Insurance 800.771.8557 800.243.5860, press 1
Kemper Insurance 866.675.3345 800.464.5108
Mutual Benefit Insurance 800.283.3531 800.290.6361
Nationwide Private Client 855.473.6410 855.473.6410
Penn National Insurance 800.388.4764 800.388.4764, press 1
Progressive Insurance 800.888.7764 800.274.4499, press 6
Pure Insurance 888.813.7873 888.813.7873, press 1
Safeco Insurance 877.566.6001 800.332.3226, press 1
Selective Insurance 800.777.9656 866.455.9969
Selective Flood Insurance 877.348.0552 877.348.0552, press 4
State Auto 800.444.9950 800.766.1853, press 2 than 3
Travelers Insurance 877.878.2468 800.252.4633, press 1