Home and Auto Insurance Bill Payment

Manage your bills online.

To pay your home and/or auto insurance bill online, please see your insurance carrier name below.


  • Pay by Phone: (866) 856-6855 and select option 1. Credit cards can be used to pay full account balances only. We accept American Express, Visa and MasterCard.
  • Online: aig.com/us/pcg

Brethren Mutual

  • Pay by Phone: (800) 621-4264, Check, Money Order, Credit Card: VISA, MasterCard or Discover.
  • Online: https://www.bmic.com/


  • Pay by Phone: (800) 682-4822, (Checks Only) There is a $1.95 fee for checks by phone. NO Credit/Debit Cards.
  • Online: chubb.com
  • Insured has to set up an account and then click ln “Pay My Bill” anywhere on Chubb’s website and it will take them to CheckFree’s website and follow instructions.

Donegal / Peninsula


  • Pay by Phone: (877) 870-3277, Check by phone, Debit/Credit Cards: VISA,MasterCard, American Express & Discover.
  • Automated Phone Payments: (866)430-2916, Code: last 5 digits of policy number is required.
  • Online: encompassinsurance.com

Hanover Insurance

The Hartford


Mutual Benefit

  • Pay by Phone: (888) 505-0153, VISA/MasterCard (Credit or Debit). No check by phone.
  • Online: mutualbenefitgroup.com

Montgomery/Ohio Casualty

  • Pay by Phone: (877) 675-4411, VISA or MasterCard Credit for full pay only. VISA or MasterCard Debit for installments only.
  • Online: ohiocasualty-ins.com/billing

Nationwide / Allied / Harleysville

  • Pay by Phone: (800) 282-1446, option 2. Choose from EZ Check: A one-time payment from your bank account. Payment by credit or debit card (Visa or MasterCard).
  • Online: https://www.nationwide.com/


Penn National




  • Pay by Phone: (800) 332-3226, then press 1, then 2. Check, VISA, MasterCard, Discover & American Express.
  • Online: safeco.com


  • Pay by Phone: (888) 974-7400, Check, VISA & MasterCard (Credit or Debit)
  • Online: selective Go to Customer Links – Pay My Bill

Selective Flood

  • Pay by Phone: (877) 348-0552, option 1. Credit Cards by phone VISA, MasterCard, Discover, American Express & Diner’s Club. No checks by phone.
  • Online: not available

State Auto


  • Pay by Phone: CHECK (800) 550-7716 (24/7); CREDIT CARD (877)872-8737, VISA & MasterCard-Credit/Debit
  • Online: mytravelers.com